top of page

Editorial: What Would Chiune Sugihara Do?

Updated: Mar 24


History is full of haunting examples of man’s capacity for cruelty. We can look as recently as the genocidal assault on Gaza and the terrorizing of the West Bank, or further back at the mass slaughter of native Americans. We can look at slavery in the U.S. and at the Holocaust, or at the U.S.’s atomic bombings of Japan. We can look at the millions who died in Russia under Stalin’s rule or in China under Mao Zedong’s. We can also look at Japan’s atrocities in China in the early half of the 1900s – in Nanjing, at Unit 731 and elsewhere.


The point is that nations can at one point be the hero and at another time be the villain. And when people act as a mob, they can inflict much pain, especially when led by bullies with power they don’t deserve. This is true whether in schoolyards, small towns, or in nations or empires. But don’t forget, throughout history, we can also find the rare, self-sacrificing hero. Today, as we see particular bullies who have police forces and military forces ready to do their dirty work, heroes are more necessary than ever. This is why we want to shine a spotlight on one of modern time’s most important heroes: Chiune Sugihara. Sugihara was born into a nation, Japan, that would by his adult years become one of the world’s most violent aggressors, before becoming one of the world’s most unfortunate victims.


But he did not follow the mob. Fluent in Russian and well educated at an exclusive university, Sugihara probably could have settled into a cushy government job and provided a safe, comfortable living for himself and his then young family. But just years after working out a deal for Japan to buy the North Manchurian railroad from the Soviet Union in the early 1930s, he would be faced with a choice: to throw his arms up at the world's horrors or to use the little power his career gave him to help as many desperate people who were born in the wrong time and place as he possibly could.


Sugihara; public domain photo/wikicommons
Sugihara; public domain photo/wikicommons

As the world was descending into one of its darkest periods, Sugihara would become the first Japanese diplomat in Lithuania. Around that time, in 1940, Stalin’s Soviet forces began occupying that small northeastern European nation. Jewish people from Poland who had been fleeing to Lithuania were now becoming even more trapped between the expanding Soviet and Nazi forces. So were those within that country.


Now, here’s where Sugihara could have faced people coming to his one-man post for help — an escape from Soviet and Nazi aggressions — and said, “Sorry, I can’t help you; I’m just doing my job” or “I’m just following orders.”


Instead, he defied orders from Tokyo and in an elaborate scheme he issued as many visas as his tired hands could stamp to allow refugees a shot at escape. He would issue thousands of these special transit visas, despite warnings from his bosses to cut it out, before eventually being detained in Romania by the Soviets with his family for a period of time before returning to Japan.


Sugihara rejected the mob, and rejected his orders. He did what was right. And in doing so, he set a rare example for the rest of us.


This editorial was edited to avoid implying Sugihara's detention was directly because of the issuance of visas as a reader pointed out.

1 Comment


Arlette
Mar 23

Your recent editorial titled, “What Would Chiune Sugihara Do?” invokes the story of the Japanese diplomat who issued transit visas to Jewish refugees in Kaunas in 1940, a history that directly affected my own family. Sugihara’s actions remain an extraordinary example of moral courage during one of history’s darkest moments. For that reason, his story deserves to be presented with care and historical accuracy.

The editorial states that Sugihara issued visas “despite his eventual arrest—and years-long detention—for him and his family by the Soviet government,” implying that Soviet authorities punished him for helping Jewish refugees. That is not correct. Sugihara and his family were detained by Soviet authorities only after the end of the Second World War, when the Soviet…


Like
bottom of page